Welcome to the
BLACK LAGOON
at Forgotten Tonic
Ample outdoor seating so you can enjoy spooky St. Augustine!
Diabolically Delicious, Creepy & Creative Libations
Black Lagoon is an immersive, creepy-as-hell cocktail experience that pays homage to the macabre and throws in a splash of goth and metal for good measure. Wear your costume to our dark dungeon of drink and enjoy innovative and deliciously spooky cocktails!
While reservations are not required to dine or enjoy cocktails with us, it is highly recommended. To make a reservation, please use the OpenTable app below or call us directly at (904) 827-9055 to reserve your table.
Card Card Required
We require a credit card to secure reservations. All credit card information will be processed securely. No-shows or cancellations less than 1 day in advance will be subject to a charge of $15 per person. Changes to guest count made less than 1 day in advance will be subject to a charge of $15 per person.
Grace Period
We have a 10 minute grace period. Please call us if you are running later than 10 minutes after your reservation time.
Large Groups
We do not seat groups larger than 8 guests during normal business hours. We do however offer the opportunity to rent out our entire space for a set period of time. Please fill out this form for a quote.
WITCHY OFFERINGS
-
HEX APPEAL
FORDS GIN • HONEYDEW • LEMON • LUSTAU VERMUT DRY • SELTZER • ABSINTHE
-
MEMENTO MORI
MEZCAL UNION • GIFFARD BANANE • MR. BLACK COLD BREW LIQUEUR • COLD BREW • BITTER QUEENS CHINESE 5 SPICE BITTERS
-
NOSFERATU’S RISE
COCONUT WASHED LOT 40 RYE WHISKY • CINNAMON • LUSTAU AMONTILLADO SHERRY • BITTER QUEENS CARIBBEAN BITTERS
-
SIREN’S SONG
LOT 40 RYE WHISKY • GIFFARD CARIBBEAN PINEAPPLE • JAMAICAN RUM • SPICED OAT ORGEAT • LUSTAUAMONTILLADO SHERRY • LIME • CARIBBEAN BITTERS
Dig into our food and drink menus
To enhance our team's benefits, we've introduced an optional surcharge on all bills. This contribution directly supports the dedicated staff responsible for your dining experience, including many behind-the-scenes team members. The surcharge helps fund essential benefits like health, dental, and vision insurance, maternity leave, and paid time off. If you have any questions or prefer not to participate, please inform your server or request to speak with a manager. For further insight into the reasons behind this surcharge, we invite you to click here.
“Obsessed is an understatement. Definitely our favorite stop!”
Private Events
We love hosting private events. It is our hope you not only enjoy our food and drink offerings but the memorable time spent with those around you. You are welcome at our tables just as you would be in our home.
